Greetings to all,. In Toby Lester’s article “What is the Koran?”, published in the January issue of The Atlantic Monthly, a German scholar, Dr. Gerd-R. Puin, . “Gerd-R. Puin’s current thinking about the Koran’s history partakes of this contemporary revisionism. ‘My idea is that the Koran is a kind of. View Gerd Puin’s business profile at The Quran and see work history, affiliations and more.

Author: Faebar Mikataxe
Country: Belgium
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Love
Published (Last): 5 March 2005
Pages: 279
PDF File Size: 16.4 Mb
ePub File Size: 8.22 Mb
ISBN: 387-5-50268-188-9
Downloads: 52044
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Tejas

Gerd R. Puin – Wikidata

If the Koran is not comprehensible—if it can’t even be understood in Arabic—then it’s not translatable. East Dane Designer Men’s Fashion. It may include stories that were written before the prophet Mohammed began his ministry and which have subsequently been rewritten. Zaid’s proposal was arguably less radical than Puin’s.

Retrieved from ” https: Coins use the term Zion as a code as a zionist only would. I’d like to read this book on Kindle Don’t have a Kindle? Orthodox Muslims have always held that the Koran is a scripture in its own right, and never a shortened version of the Bible, even if both texts contain the same prophetic tradition.

The first two Islamic centuries ] in German 1st ed. However, a few chapters are more difficult as they deal with Arabic and linguistics. Jones admits there have been “trifling” changes made to the Uthmanic recension. Warned of the possible controversy it could raise, he replied: See all 23 reviews. In an article in Atlantic Monthly, [4] Gerd Puin is quoted as saying that:.

Puin, Gerd-R [WorldCat Identities]

Khalidi fears Muslims will not accept Puin’s work on the Sa’na manuscripts as having been pujn with academic objectivity, but see it as a deliberate “attack on the integrity of the Koranic text”. And essential until we get a variorum translation of the Quran that incorporates their research and faces up to its sources on its own.

There’s a problem loading this menu right now.

It is a very interesting history of Islam and I learned a lot about the origins of the religion! The implication of these and other findings here presented is that the early Arab rulers adhered to a sect of Christianity. Orthodox Muslims insist that no changes have occurred to the Koran since the Uthmanic recension.


Amazon Drive Cloud storage from Amazon. Khalidi says the traditional Muslim account of the Koran’s development is still more or less true. Get fast, free shipping with Amazon Prime.

As a result of this explosive book, we have to face the possibility that Muhammad never existed, that the Koran was pasted together from Syric-Aramaic Christian sources, and that the whole thing was a bundle of bushwah created to defend the now “Islamic” empire.

Not all Muslim reaction to him has been hostile. Amazon Restaurants Food delivery from local restaurants. The court forced him to divorce his wife because under Islamic law, marriage between an apostate and a Muslim is forbidden. This same reference exists in the building inscription of the Dome of the Rock in Jerusalem, built by the caliph ‘Abd al-Malik.

Yet The Theory provides important points that needs extra work and clarification in order for it to be more establish in the Scholarly world.

One copy in the Library of Tashkent in Uzbekistan, and another in puln Topkapi Museum in Istanbul, Turkey, date from the eighth century. In the Shadow of the Sword: Customers who bought this item also bought. Despite Muhammad’s exalted place in Islam, even today gdrd is still surpisingly little actually known about this shadowy figure and the origins of the Qur’an because of an astounding lack of verifiable biographical material.

This page was last edited on 15 Novemberat This is blasphemy, according to orthodox Muslims, and is not entirely accepted by other academics. Based on the premise that reliable history can only be written on egrd basis of sources that are contemporary with the events described, the contributors to this in-depth investigation present research that reveals the obscure origins of Islam in a completely new light.

Al-Akwa managed to interest Puin, who was visiting Yemen for research purposes in People made changes to make sense of the text.

Querying the Koran

A Muslim, Zaid remained in Egypt for a time to refute the apostasy charges, but fled with his wife to Holland in the face of increasing death threats. As the authors meticulously show, the name “Muhammad” first appears on coins in Syria bearing Christian iconography.


Abd-el Malik and the rest. Those that were unfamiliar with the Koran would read it differently because there were no diacritical and vowel symbols. Puin, however, sees the need for a “scientific text” of the Koran, and this is what he intends to achieve. Language, Text, and Commentary. But the Sa’na manuscripts are even older.

Academics offering radical interpretations of the Koran put their lives at risk. The manuscripts, thought to be the oldest surviving copies of the Koran, were discovered in the ancient Great Mosque of Sa’na in terd, when the building was puln restored after heavy rainfall, hidden in the loft in a bundle of old parchment puun paper documents. Puin noticed minor textual variations, unconventional ordering of the chapters surahsas well as rare styles of orthography.

The Koran claims for itself that it is ‘mubeen,’ or ‘clear,’ but if you look at it, you will notice that every fifth sentence or so simply doesn’t make sense. German 17 English 10 Fang 2. Excavated coins that predate Islam and the old inscription in the Dome of the Rock in Jerusalem utilize symbols used in a documented Syrian Arabic theology – a theology with Christian roots.

Interpreting traditional contexts of historical evidence and rereading passages of the Qur’an, the researchers in this thought-provoking volume unveil a surprising – and highly unconventional – picture of the very foundations of Islamic religious history.

Withoutabox Submit to Film Festivals. Shopbop Designer Fashion Brands. Probably not for beginners. Customers who viewed this item also viewed.